三肖中特精准24码免费公开 www.syysp.icu Is eating cow more ethical than eating dog? Why?



Ariel Garlow, Studied in philosophy. Journalist, games enthusiast, vegan.

Originally Answered: Why is it okay to eat cows and chickens but not dogs or rats?

Some argue for illogical reasons: I have heard people say that "horses are majestic, pigs are ugly" which was their reason for not accepting horse meat. If beauty is the only thing keeping this individual from eating a living being, I'd be the first to go!

Many individuals grow up having pet dogs and getting to know their personal behaviours. Not too many people, in my experience, have gotten to really know a pig or a cow, and thus they assume that the reason it is 'acceptable' to eat them in society is because they do not have emotions, that they are inferior creatures. It might shock them to learn that pigs and dogs are very similar when it comes to levels of intelligence and loyalty (in fact, in many studies pigs win out on the scale of intelligence).

Rats are generally seen as vermin - dirty, diseased, and so on. They are not widely consumed by western society because of this different reason. However, rats aren't naturally dirty or vicious creatures. Anyone who has had a pet rat can account for this.





Chickens have been given the reputation of "bird brain", despite the fact that there is readily available information on the complex social conditions and familial relations of chickens:

The meat industry doesn't like it all too much having their customers question whether or not the business is "ethical". I've heard many a businessman say that ethics aren't good for business, and they are right - having people fully informed about the emotional complexities of animals commonly seen as food would ruin the future of the slaughter business.

Additionally, the way to keep 'people on the edge of ethics' in the consumer audience of animal flesh is to convince people that although "yes, it's sad that they die" we "need" meat to survive. There are hundreds upon thousands of meat-free individuals in this world - their existence is becoming more known thanks to international connection and communication (internet). Hopefully, as we continue to create a global community of easily accessible knowledge, there will also be a greater push for a meat-free lifestyle.





Suzy Sims, Real Estate Agent at Berkshire Hathaway (2018-present)

Originally Answered: How can it bother people that dogs are eaten while they are okay with eating other animals?

A while back my husband and I were having hibachi at a Japanese steak house. The other two people at the table were two young, single women. The grill chef was trying to make points with them, visiting and flirting with the women and ignoring us. The young man started in on a story of going to a party in another state at the home of the restaurant owner, and being served a meat he did not recognize. I sat and listened in stunned horror as he shared his story. I excused myself from the table and went to throw up. I did not return to the table, and complained to management. The manager did not understand why it was a problem for me. I have never been back to that restaurant. Since then, I have thought about this. Why is it literally sickening to me that people would willingly eat dogs, but not a problem to eat other animals and fish. I grew up with ranch animals. We raised cattle, sheep, goats, and chickens. We hunt and kill deer on our land. I think the biggest difference is only the horses ever connected the same way a dog does. The dogs and horses have an intuitiveness that comes from centuries of co dependency with humans. Because they have been bred to work with humans in daily activities, these animals have heightened body language and facial expression understanding. They will seek out human attention, where most other farm animals won’t unless they are looking to be fed. There are always exceptions, but for the most part the cows are not coming to you for affection. The dogs, cats, horses will come to you for company. Most dogs actually prefer to be with their humans than other dogs. So eating dogs, cats, or horses to me is almost cannibalism.

譯文來源:三泰虎  //www.syysp.icu/47681.html  譯者:Joyceliu




Nina Walker, Just throwing in my two cents worth...

Originally Answered: How can westerners be so sensitive to dogs and cats, and insensitive towards cows and pigs?

Yes, we do feel differently about our pets than we do the animals we eat, but it's because we have to eat them that we don't allow ourselves to get attached to them. 

Not all of us are vegetarians and I am tired of apologizing for being an omnivore, like most people are all over the world. This is our nature, this is what we eat, fruits vegetables and meat, all kinds of meat. Our teeth were designed for it, our bodies need the protein and other nutrients. 

Some of us make a conscious choice to not eat as much or any meat. Good for you, but your morality is not my morality, nor do you have the right to judge me or anyone for their choice in eating habits or for following the very nature they were born with.

Now, just so you know, I, too, feel there is a huge disconnect and most people don't "appreciate" the sacrifice an animal is forced to make to feed us. Because of that disconnect, we raised turkeys this year for both of our families to enjoy at Thanksgiving. Organic, farm raised and we provided the best life for them we could for our birds. The day they are to be slaughtered is approaching, and yes, it is hard! 






It is hard to look them in the eye. They are trusting and friendly birds. I have not treated them as pets, yet, I still have all the warm fuzzy feelings that I do for my cats and our chickens (whom we promised we would not eat).   I like them in spite of what I know is coming, and I really don't want to do this but we can not keep them. Our 5 turkeys are scheduled to feed 75-100 people.

If I didn't kill them, we would still have turkey for Thanksgiving, and I will have 5 huge birds that I can not continue to feed. "Big bird" is approaching 50 lbs and I had no idea they could get that big.

Evidently, normal turkeys and chickens are slaughtered when they are much younger and smaller than our birds. I have heard that slaughtering occurs as young as 10 weeks, ours are 6 months old, having reached maturity or egg laying age at 4-1/2 months.

So I am more or less moral because I gave them a longer life outside of a factory farm where they could enjoy the life they have for as long as I can let them? Am I more or less moral because I acknowledge that I have trouble looking at them knowing what I know? 






Michael Shaw, I eat

Originally Answered: Why do Westerners care so much about people eating dogs but don't care about people eating any other animals?

Because human beings are not perfectly rational.

As a species, we're prone to having subjective experiences and emotions inform our opinions, along with hard information and objective reason.

Mainstream Western cultures are far removed the process of food production. Most of us have never had to kill something in order to eat it, nor have most of us ever witnessed an animal slaughter in person (meaning, Youtube videos don't count.) So, we don't really need to think about exactly where our meat came from; we just grab it from the refrigerated shelves at the supermarket, and then carry on down to the dairy section.

As a result, we have a rather narrow view of which animals are food, and which aren't. If it's a farmed animal, then it must be for eating. If it's not a farmed animal, then it must not be for eating. Hunted animals, like deer, are an exception.

Dogs are very firmly in the "friend" category. People view their pet dogs as members of the family, and most people can't imagine eating them for that reason. Cats are viewed much the same way.







I find it interesting that rabbits are in both the "friend" and "food" categories. They're a common pet, yet also known as a food item. Certainly not one of the most common proteins available, but many people have eaten rabbit and there is no stigma against it.

So, this all just shows that humanity's ideas about the value of life are extremely subjective. Different cultures/societies develop different values regarding the role of animals, which are okay to eat, etc. Some people become vegetarians, who don't eat meat, but would still be fine with squishing a spider. Some people will call themselves vegetarians, but still eat chicken or fish, as if they're not animals. Some people will be vegan, and try their best to never be complicit in the harm of an animal, whereas some people will eat anything as long as it's actually edible. We can't really say that one set of values is objectively more correct than another.




Yveline Burton, Long time dog lover, and self taught force-free training enthusiast.

Originally Answered: How can westerners be so sensitive to dogs and cats, and insensitive towards cows and pigs?

Its partly culture, and partly holding different attitudes towards different animals.

Culture is purely what you are told is food by all around you as you grow up. Having French roots I have no issue with trying meats on the continent (like horse, or rabbit) that many of my friends in the UK would feel disgusted by. I get it, though. Its difficult to say to yourself 'I wouldn't think like this if I had been born in country X instead of country Y' because those irrational beliefs and traditions are so deeply ingrained. To someone whose only ever seen cute little bunnies as something to love, it seems abhorrent to eat one, just like to those who've only ever seen insects as something dirty, it seems disgusting to even think of cooking them!

Attitudes are different in my eyes -the aren't quite so ingrained and it only takes experience to break them.

I know many people who are quite happy to buy battery farm eggs/meat because 'They're only chickens'. They see farm animals as dumb. As subordinate to the animals whose intelligence and personality we see on a daily basis. I've been actively laughed at for choosing only to eat our own eggs or buy free range and for asking others to do the same. "Its just a scam to get you to pay more, so that a dumb animal can wander around a bigger space - its not like they even notice". All it takes to change that view of the world is to meet a few.






My chickens are not 'dumb', they aren't so smart, but if you treat them right they will be just as loving and full of character as any domestic pet. When people see them hop onto my lap, and close their eyes in a visible sign of comfort as I stroke them, when they see them tap at the living room window to be thrown scraps from my sandwich, then they often go home a little sickened by the thought of those same loving creatures spending their life in a tiny cage, pecked clean of feathers and covered in faeces.

Its just the same with other farm animals - pigs are 'dirty', cows and sheep are 'stupid'. The people who say this have often never really met one of these animal for any prolonged period of time, never trained one to do something amazing, never seen one care for its young or play with other animals. They just don't realise that the only difference between their beloved hamster, rabbit, cat or dog, and the animals whose meat they so readily buy cheap at the supermarket with no thought for welfare standards, is that the ones they eat aren't practical house-pets, so they don't see how great they are.

Being a butcher's granddaughter, I have no qualms about any eating meat, as long as I wouldn't be ashamed by what I saw if I visited the farm where it had lived, nor shocked by the manner in which it died. Good clean life and a quick clean death.





Keely Meakin, B.S. Zoology & Minor in Anthropology

short answer: NO. A lot of the responses here are saying ‘as long as the animal had a good life prior to the slaughtering, it it ethical.’ But why? Say you are taking care of your pet dog or cow and then while walking down the street someone just kills your dog/cow. Wow, so ethical right? Both cow and dog had a desire for life and were murdered against their will. Especially today where (in most developed countries at least) meat is NOT a necessity. There are hundreds of alternatives that give you better sources of nutrients and protein that the murdering of any creature for food is immoral. If it is the only option (i.e. someone that is very poor and has no other food source) then I can slightly understand but killing to kill when there are other humane alternatives is wrong. Cows want to live just as much as a dog wants to. It comes down to culture at this point. Just because it is okay (by societies’ standards) in one culture doesn’t make it okay overall. Marital rape, for example, is not punished in some cultures but does it mean it is okay overall? NO. There is nothing ethical about killing any being that doesn’t want to die in the first place. Look up the video ‘Dominion’, ‘Forks over knives’, and ‘cowspiracy.’ They all touch on the many cruel aspects of the slaughter of cows, chickens, and pigs etc. This isn’t even considering the environmental damages the animal agriculture industry is doing; species are going extinct, forests are being completely demolished, the waterways are being overfished, and many more. Veganism is the solution.



Kandyce Perez

Originally Answered: Why is it okay to eat cows and chickens but not dogs or rats?

Having grown up around pigs and dogs, and consuming the pigs I've raised, but not the dogs, I have thought about this question. My answer is that I would not be disposed to eat an animal who eats mainly meat. I just don't think they would be very tasty. ( I wouldn't be disposed to eat wild boar for instance, because pigs really will eat anything and I think it would be super gamey). I would totally eat horse though, I hear it is delicious and very mild, and I believe that, based on the very specific diet of horses.

I believe that people often give animals anthropomorphic qualities, such as love and compassion, and that stops them from consuming certain animals. Rather, I ascribe different uses to animals. For me dogs are companion animals, some bunnies are pets, others are delicious. I would totally have a pet pig, as they are entertaining and delightful animals, but I'm still going to eat bacon.

I think horses in American economy are way too expensive to eat. I fully realize that this way of thinking leads me to be viewed as a horrible and heartless person, but my very close connection with every part of many animals lives has led me to view humans and animals differently. I appreciate and adore animals. I love the pack qualities of dogs and horses that are often used to develop close bonds between those animals and their human caretakers. I also know what animals do and how they behave when left to their own devices (wild boar are terrifying, for instance, and a domesticated pig turns into a wild boar within three months of being in the wild). People love cats, but colonies of feral cats are no joke, and they would totally kill you if they were the size of their larger cousins. I personally love foxes, but they are also vicious carnivores, they're just really cute ones.

So in rambling conclusion, I believe that people choose to eat one animal above another because they have ascribed certain qualities on those animals. I personally make my choices based on what I know of an animals diet, because diet changes the taste of meat.






三泰虎原創譯文,禁止轉載?。?a href="//www.syysp.icu/">首頁 > 美國 » 美版知乎:吃牛肉比吃狗肉更道德嗎


全天极速时时计划软件 大小最稳玩法 乐米彩票app 三星组选包胆怎么玩 足球比分直播500 北京pk开奖结果 快速时时是官方吗 分分彩独胆 手机棋牌游戏 北京pk10代玩骗局 网彩 全盛棋牌6元app不洗牌 双色球复中隔走势 二人棋牌有哪些 捕鱼达人开发 公式单双怎么算大发快三